VOTING RIGHTS ACT STATISTICS IN SUPREME COURT: Charles Ware's Blog

www.CharlesJeromeWare.com ("We fight. You win.")

ELECTION LAW: Did Chief Justice Roberts Misuse Statistics To Make His Point On The Voting Rights Act Last Week?

The New York Times blogger and statistical whiz who correctly predicted President Obama’s re-election success has a bone to pick with Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.

At issue is a comment by Roberts during oral arguments last week on the constitutionality of preclearance requirements in the Voting Rights Act. Under Section 5 of the law, states and jurisdictions with a history of discrimination are required to get advance approval of voting rights changes. Roberts said that Massachusetts, which is not covered by the law, “has the worst ratio of white voter turnout to African-American voter turnout,” the New York Times reported at the time. Mississippi, on the other hand has the best ratio, the chief justice said.

Writing at the New York Times blog FiveThirtyEight, Silver says Roberts appeared to be citing 2004 census bureau data referenced in a lower court brief. Those statistics found that white voter turnout in Massachusetts was 72 percent while black turnout was a much lower 46.5 percent. In Mississippi, on the other hand, white voter turnout was 60.2 percent and black turnout was a higher 66.8 percent.

But Roberts focused on two states without looking at broader trends, Silver says. The blogger charted 2004 voter turnout data in all the states that are subject to the preclearance requirement and those that are not. Differences in white-to-black voting ratios between the two sets of states are so small, Silver says, that they are not “meaningful in either a statistical or a practical sense.”

“So did Chief Justice Roberts misconstrue the data?” Silver writes. “If he meant to suggest that states covered by Section 5 consistently have better black turnout rates than those that aren’t covered by the statute, then his claim is especially dubious. However, the evidence does support the more modest claim that black turnout is no worse in states covered by Section 5.”

The bigger flaw in Roberts’ argument, Silver concludes, is his suggestion that an increase over the years in black voter turnout in Section 5 states is evidence that the law is unnecessary. Perhaps the statistics mean the law has been effective, Silver says.

“As much as it pleases me to see statistical data introduced in the Supreme Court,” Silver writes, “the act of citing statistical factoids is not the same thing as drawing sound inferences from them.”

[www.abajournal.com/news/article/03-08-2013/ "Did Chief Justice Misuse Statistics To Make A Point On The Voting Rights Act?"; fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/03-07-2013/ "In Supreme Court Debate On Voting Rights Act, A Dubious Use of Statistics"/ The New York Times]

Charles Jerome Ware, PA, Attorneys & Counselors

Personal Injury, Wrongful Death, Civil& Criminal Trial Practice
Serving Maryland & The DC Metropolitan Area For Over 22 Yearswww.charlesjeromeware.com

Charles Jerome Ware is considered, and has been named, one of the “Best Lawyers” in America. Charles Jerome Ware and his colleagues have built this specialty law practice on promptness, personal client attention and answers when you need him. Located in Columbia at 10630 Little Patuxent Parkway, Suite 113, phone (410) 720-6129or (410) 730-5016, he is there to serve you—the client! They handle wrongful death, personal injury, class actions, and major civil and criminal trials. Charles Jerome Ware also offers free consultations for personal injury, wrongful death and medical malpractice claims. His fees are reasonable, and his individual attention to each case is outstanding.

He is rated a “Great Lawyer,” is the original recipient of the Charles Hamilton Houston Award for “Outstanding Litigation, and he is a former “Chief Justice Earl Warren Scholar.”

Since going to court can be an anxious experience, Charles Jerome Ware wants you to know he is sensitive to the emotional turmoil which often accompanies the need for legal services. When you are faced with legal problems, turn to him for the best solution. You may call the office at (410) 720-6129 or (410) 730-5016 for a legal consultation. Visit his Web site at www.charlesjeromeware.com.